Home Seafood 5 Best Cheese for Chicken Sandwich: Savoring Harmony
Best Cheese for Chicken Sandwich

5 Best Cheese for Chicken Sandwich: Savoring Harmony

by zilvinas.juraska

Indulge your taste buds in a symphony of flavors as we embark on a culinary journey to uncover the art of the perfect chicken sandwich. Picture this: succulent, seasoned chicken nestled between two pillowy slices of bread, warmed to perfection. But wait, there’s more to this masterpiece! 

Imagine the irresistible allure of melted cheese cascading over the tender chicken, infusing every bite with a harmonious blend of textures and tastes. In this tantalizing exploration, we unveil the top contenders for the title of “Best Cheese for Chicken Sandwich.” From the creamy classics that invoke nostalgia to the bold, contemporary contenders that push the boundaries, we leave no slice unturned. 

Whether you’re a cheese connoisseur or a sandwich enthusiast, join us in discovering how the right cheese can elevate your chicken sandwich experience to a whole new level of savory satisfaction. Get ready to savor the symphony – it’s time to explore the five best cheeses that transform a chicken sandwich into pure harmony.

The Perfect Pair: Exploring the Best Cheese for Chicken Sandwiches

1. Sargento® Sliced Colby-Jack Natural Cheese, 11 slices

Sargento® Sliced Colby-Jack Natural Cheese

As a loyal user of Sargento® Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Slices, I can confidently say that this cheese has elevated my culinary experiences. The marbled orange and white appearance adds a touch of elegance to my cheese platters during family gatherings and parties. The convenience of pre-sliced and well-packaged freshness has made it my go-to choice for picnics and tailgate parties. The versatility of this cheese truly shines – from the delightful melt it creates on cheeseburgers and paninis to its irresistible flavor on cold sandwiches.

Price: $3.56

Check the Current Price on Walmart


  • Flavorful and Fresh: The cheese’s rich flavor and paper-thin slices make every bite a delight.
  • Versatile Melt: It melts beautifully on various dishes like grilled cheese sandwiches, burgers, and nachos.
  • Convenient Packaging: The Easy-close FreshLock® packaging ensures prolonged freshness, perfect for extended events.
  • Attractive Appearance: The marbled orange and white appearance adds a visual appeal to any dish or platter.
  • Quality Ingredients: Made with 100% real, natural ingredients, including plant-derived annatto for color.


  • Mold Issues: Some users have reported mold appearing shortly after opening, leading to disappointment.
  • Thin Slices: The thinness of the slices can sometimes make it difficult to separate for certain uses.
  • Delivery Concerns: In hot climates, improper delivery without coolers can lead to issues like stuck slices and compromised quality.


In conclusion, Sargento® Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Slices have greatly enhanced my culinary adventures. Their delectable flavor, versatility in melting, and eye-catching appearance make them a staple for gatherings and meals. However, occasional concerns about mold and the thinness of slices warrant careful handling and prompt consumption. If you’re seeking a cheese that adds a gourmet touch to your dishes and gatherings, Sargento® Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Slices are an excellent choice, offering both convenience and flavor.

2. Kraft Singles American Cheese Slices, 16 Ct Pk

Kraft Singles American Cheese Slices

As a dedicated user of Kraft Singles American Cheese Slices, I can confidently say that this product has been a staple in my kitchen for quite some time. From its convenience to its delightful flavor, it has seamlessly woven its way into my culinary routines. Whether it’s crafting a quick sandwich, grilling up a burger, or even adding a cheesy twist to comfort foods, these cheese slices have consistently delivered.

Price: $4.28

Check the Current Price on Walmart


  • Convenience: The individually wrapped slices make meal preparation a breeze, especially when I’m in a hurry.
  • Versatility: These cheese slices enhance a wide range of dishes, from sandwiches to casseroles, with their smooth melt and savory taste.
  • Meltability: The cheese’s ability to melt perfectly makes it an excellent addition to both hot and cold dishes.
  • Flavor: The classic American cheese taste is deliciously mild and savory, making it a crowd-pleaser for all ages.
  • Stackable & Snackable: Being individually wrapped, they’re easy to store and grab for a quick snack.
  • Quality Ingredients: Made with real dairy and without artificial flavors or preservatives, I feel good about the quality.


  • Nutritional Content: The cheese’s high sodium content might be a concern for those watching their salt intake.
  • Processed Nature: While it’s convenient, some may prefer less processed cheese options for health reasons.


Kraft Singles American Cheese Slices have earned their spot in my kitchen due to their convenience, versatile applications, and delightful taste. From grilling to snacking, they consistently deliver the meltiness and flavor that I expect from quality American cheese. While there are nutritional considerations, the overall experience and culinary possibilities make these cheese slices a dependable choice for a variety of dishes.

3. Great Value Deli Style Sliced Non-Smoked Provolone Cheese, 8 oz, 12 Count

Great Value Deli Style Sliced Non-Smoked Provolone Cheese

As a consumer of the Great Value Deli Style Sliced Non-Smoked Provolone Cheese, I’ve found it to be a convenient and versatile addition to my meals. The cheese’s mild flavor reminiscent of mozzarella makes it a great choice for a variety of dishes. 

Whether I’m melting a slice onto oven-roasted chicken for a delectable chicken provolone or crafting a hearty vegetarian panini, the cheese adds a delightful touch. Its gluten-free nature aligns well with my dietary preferences, and the good calcium content is a bonus.

Price: $2.46

Check the Current Price on Walmart


  • Mild and versatile flavor, suitable for various dishes
  • Easy-to-use deli-style slices
  • Good source of calcium
  • Gluten-free, catering to dietary needs
  • Resealable packaging maintains freshness


  • Inconsistent quality based on customer reviews
  • Reports of mold issues in some packages


The Great Value Deli Style Sliced Non-Smoked Provolone Cheese offers a convenient and cost-effective option for enhancing meals. Its mild flavor and versatility make it suitable for a range of recipes, from sandwiches to melts. While the majority of reviews highlight its positive attributes, some customers have reported issues with mold and packaging inconsistencies. As such, while it’s a convenient choice, it might be wise to inspect the product upon purchase. Considering the affordable price point and overall positive feedback, it remains a viable choice for those seeking an accessible and tasty cheese option for their meals.

4. Frigo Cheese Heads Original Mozzarella String Cheese, 16 Oz, 16 Ct

Frigo Cheese

As a devoted consumer of Frigo Cheese Heads® String Cheese, I’ve found this product to be an exceptional choice for my snacking needs. The creamy and delicious low moisture part-skim mozzarella cheese is conveniently wrapped individually, making it a perfect on-the-go snack for both me and my family. With its 80 calories per serving and 6 grams of protein, it strikes a satisfying balance between flavor and nutrition. The versatility of this cheese is also impressive – from simple snacking to enhancing homemade treats like mozzarella sticks, it adds a delightful touch to various meals. The overwhelmingly positive customer reviews, particularly the 5-star ratings, resonate with my own experience.

Price: $4.97

Check the Current Price on Walmart


  • Creamy and delicious mozzarella cheese with a satisfying texture.
  • Individually wrapped portions ensure convenience and freshness.
  • Excellent nutritional profile with 6 grams of protein per serving.
  • Versatile usage in snacking and cooking, adding flavor to various dishes.
  • Positive customer reviews highlight its great taste and convenience.


  • Some negative reviews mentioned issues like expired products, moldy sticks, or missing items.
  • Inconsistent quality in larger packages due to storage and transport concerns.


Frigo Cheese Heads® String Cheese has undeniably earned its reputation as a top-tier snack option. Its creamy texture, delicious taste, and convenience make it a go-to choice for on-the-go families and snack enthusiasts. While occasional quality issues in larger packages might be a concern, the smaller packs provide consistent results. This product’s positive attributes far outweigh the drawbacks, and I wholeheartedly recommend it to anyone seeking a flavorful and protein-packed snack that can elevate a variety of culinary experiences.

5. Tillamook Sliced Colby Jack & Monterey Jack Cheese, 2 lb, 42 Ct

Tillamook Sliced Colby Jack & Monterey Jack Cheese

As a consumer who enjoys both convenience and exceptional flavor, my experience with Tillamook Colby Jack Monterey Jack Cheese Slices has been delightfully positive. The product offers a convenient solution for my family’s cheese cravings with its generous 2 lb package containing 42 slices. The combination of Colby Jack and Monterey Jack flavors provides a delicious variety for sandwiches and other dishes.

The resealable packaging ensures the cheese remains fresh over time, reducing wastage. Tillamook’s commitment to quality shines through in every bite, as the cheese is smooth, flavorful, and free from artificial preservatives. Being made from milk sourced from cows not treated with rBST adds to the product’s appeal.

Price: $10.98

Check the Current Price on Walmart


  • Abundant quantity with 42 slices in a 2 lb package
  • Resealable bag maintains freshness
  • Rich blend of Colby Jack and Monterey Jack flavors
  • No artificial preservatives
  • Use of milk from cows not treated with rBST
  • Slices are convenient for sandwiches and snacking
  • Smooth and flavorful texture
  • Tradition-driven quality from Tillamook County Creamery Association


  • Limited diversity in cheese options (only Colby Jack and Monterey Jack)
  • One report of mold within the packaging (individual experience)


Tillamook’s Colby Jack Monterey Jack Cheese Slices offer a fantastic solution for cheese enthusiasts seeking both convenience and flavor excellence. The product’s large quantity of slices and resealable packaging make it a practical choice for households. The cheese’s high quality and commitment to using wholesome ingredients are evident in its taste and texture. However, a single report of mold within the packaging is a concern, though this seems to be an isolated incident. Overall, Tillamook delivers on its promise of providing smooth, flavorful cheeses that elevate everyday meals. Whether for sandwiches or snacking, these cheese slices are a delectable addition to any kitchen.

Five tips for choosing the best cheese for your chicken sandwich

1. Flavor Synergy:

When selecting cheese for your chicken sandwich, it’s important to consider how the flavors of the cheese and the chicken will interact. Aim for cheeses that enhance the taste of the chicken without overpowering it. For a classic and versatile option, Swiss cheese offers a mild, nutty flavor that complements various seasonings. Mozzarella, with its delicate and slightly sweet profile, can provide a creamy and subtle backdrop to the chicken’s taste. Provolone, on the other hand, introduces a touch of tanginess that can cut through richer components like sauces or marinades.

2. Meltability Matters:

The allure of a chicken sandwich lies in the moment when you take that first bite and experience the delightful melding of flavors. To achieve this, prioritize cheeses with excellent meltability. Cheddar is a prime example, known for its smooth melt that wraps around the chicken, infusing every mouthful with a satisfying creaminess. American cheese, often lauded for its melt-in-your-mouth quality, is a classic choice for creating that comforting texture. Pepper jack, with its hint of spiciness, not only melts well but also adds a kick to your sandwich.

3. Texture Balance:

A harmonious chicken sandwich entails a balance of textures that contribute to an enjoyable bite. Soft and gooey cheeses like brie or camembert bring a luxurious creaminess that blends seamlessly with tender chicken. These cheeses offer a rich mouthfeel that adds an extra layer of comfort. On the flip side, aged cheeses such as parmesan, asiago, or pecorino provide a gratifying crunch that contrasts the chicken’s succulence. Grated or shaved, these cheeses can also bring a bold burst of flavor.

4. Consider Condiments:

The cheeses you choose should complement any sauces or condiments you plan to include in your sandwich. Creamy sauces like ranch or aioli pair well with cheeses that have a similar smooth texture. Creamier cheeses like cream cheese or goat cheese can offer a harmonious match, enhancing the overall creamy experience. For those who prefer a zingy or spicy kick, tangy cheeses like feta or blue cheese can enhance the flavors of sauces, creating a dynamic taste sensation.

5. Experiment and Personalize:

The world of cheese is vast and diverse, so don’t hesitate to experiment and find unique combinations that suit your preferences. If you’re looking to infuse a Mediterranean flair, consider pairing feta cheese with grilled chicken, olives, and roasted red peppers. Alternatively, smoked gouda can lend a smoky depth that complements BBQ sauce and caramelized onions. Don’t be afraid to mix and match different cheeses to create a sandwich that resonates with your personal taste buds. After all, the joy of culinary exploration is discovering unexpected and delightful combinations that make your chicken sandwich truly one-of-a-kind.

Final Words

In the world of culinary craftsmanship, crafting the perfect chicken sandwich is an art that goes beyond the basic assembly of ingredients. It’s a symphony of flavors, textures, and aromas that come together to create a mouthwatering masterpiece. As we conclude our journey through the “5 Best Cheese for Chicken Sandwich: Savoring Harmony,” we hope you’ve gained insights into the dynamic interplay between cheese and chicken. The right cheese has the power to elevate a simple sandwich into an unforgettable experience—a blend of comfort and excitement that dances on your taste buds.

Whether you opt for the creamy allure of Swiss cheese, the nostalgic embrace of cheddar, the luxuriousness of brie, or any other combination, remember that your chicken sandwich is an expression of your individuality. Each bite is an opportunity to experiment, personalize, and create a fusion that resonates uniquely with your palate. So, whether you’re a connoisseur of classics or an explorer of novel tastes, embrace the delightful journey of crafting your perfect chicken sandwich, complete with the best cheese that speaks to you.

As you embark on future culinary endeavors, may you find joy in the symphony of flavors, and may every bite be a reminder of the delectable harmony you’ve discovered. Here’s to savoring every moment of your culinary explorations and celebrating the marriage of cheese and chicken in each delectable mouthful.

You may also like

Leave a Comment